Updated ETGet the DI Daily by Email

Technology news for e-commerce professionals, with our take on why it matters.

Developing story: Visa and Mastercard swipe fee settlement awaits court ruling

Judge weighs Visa and Mastercard settlement letting retailers refuse premium cards

Judge weighs Visa and Mastercard settlement letting retailers refuse premium cards
Image: PYMNTS

If approved, stores could test refusing premium credit cards for 180 days a year, and standard card interchange would be capped at 1.25% for eight years.

Source: PYMNTS

Visa and Mastercard asked U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan on November 16 to grant final approval to their swipe fee settlement, PYMNTS reported. Cogan ended the Brooklyn hearing without ruling. Walmart, Circle K and the National Retail Federation oppose the deal.

As drafted, the settlement would let retailers test refusing a network's premium consumer credit cards at selected stores while still accepting its standard consumer cards, according to PYMNTS. Retailers could also test refusing commercial credit cards. Each pilot is limited to 180 days in a 12-month period and can cover up to 20% of a banner's outlets, or, for chains in at least five states, all same-banner outlets in up to two states if those are no more than half its stores. Retailers must give the network and acquirer a rollout schedule or at least 30 days' written notice. The networks would have 90 days after approval to amend their rules.

The agreement caps posted interchange on standard consumer credit cards at 1.25% for eight years and lets merchants offer discounts that vary by card issuer, PYMNTS reported. Retailers must disclose acceptance practices at checkout without suggesting the network made the refusal decision.

Retail groups argue stores will still face pressure to accept premium cards. Mithun Mansinghani, an attorney for Circle K and the National Association of Convenience Stores, said the agreement falls short of creating meaningful competition among card issuers, according to CPI coverage citing Reuters.

Read the full article at PYMNTS

Our take

If Cogan approves the deal, large US merchants get a capped standard-card rate and a formal way to test whether refusing premium cards saves more in fees than it loses in sales.

  • Model the savings against likely abandonment for candidate pilot stores now.
  • Ask your acquirer how it would handle pilot notices and checkout disclosures.
  • Watch the ruling, since Walmart and the NRF still oppose the terms.

Was our take useful?

Key takeaways

  1. Judge Brian Cogan heard final approval arguments on November 16 and has not ruled
  2. Pilots refusing premium cards limited to 180 days in a 12-month period
  3. Proposed cap on standard consumer credit interchange: 1.25% for eight years

More on this topic

Illustration for Visa and Mastercard swipe fee settlement awaits court ruling
Illustration: Digital Influence

Developing story2 postsUpdated Nov 17

Visa and Mastercard swipe fee settlement awaits court ruling

Visa and Mastercard are seeking final approval of a settlement that would let retailers pilot refusing premium cards and cap standard credit interchange at 1.25%, PYMNTS reports.