U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan told merchants, Visa and Mastercard at a Monday hearing in Brooklyn that he has not yet decided whether to give final approval to their proposed swipe fee settlement, Payments Dive reported. He said the case will go to trial in 2027 if he rejects it, and that he would not do "any more head-banging to get a settlement." He said he will rule as soon as possible.
The settlement would trim credit interchange rates by 10 basis points for five years and set a 1.25% rate for standard consumer cards for eight years. It would let merchants decline some premium and commercial credit cards, a departure from the networks' honor all cards rule, and add rights to surcharge and offer discounts. Cogan granted preliminary approval in June; a different judge rejected a prior settlement in June 2024.
About 1,000 larger merchants and trade groups, led by Walmart, the National Retail Federation and the National Association of Convenience Stores, have objected. Large merchants argue they can't easily reject premium cards because customers like them. Cogan said a trial would mean about two months of preparation and a roughly two-month trial, and if plaintiffs won, injunction proposals would delay a conclusion further. His decision can be appealed to the 2nd Circuit.
The case, filed in 2005, covers a class of 12 million merchants. Merchants paid a 2.35% average fee on Visa and Mastercard transactions in 2024, according to Nilson Report, and swipe fees totaled $198.3 billion last year, according to the Merchants Payments Coalition.




