Updated ETGet the DI Daily by Email

Technology news for e-commerce professionals, with our take on why it matters.

German top court asks EU court whether feed algorithms cost Meta its hosting shield

German top court asks EU court whether feed algorithms cost Meta its hosting shield
Image: PPC Land

The Bundesgerichtshof sent six questions to Luxembourg, including whether platforms must manually judge reworded copies of unlawful posts.

Source: PPC Land

Germany's Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) suspended a lawsuit over a fabricated Facebook quote on October 27, 2026, and referred six questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union, PPC Land reported. The court did not name the parties, but German media including beck-aktuell and ZDF identified them as Green Party politician Renate Künast and Meta. The meme attributes a sentence about learning Turkish to her, which she says she never said.

Künast seeks an order requiring Meta to block all identical or meaning-equivalent memes without her supplying each URL, plus at least 10,000 euros in damages. Meta's position, as the court summarized it, is that as a neutral host it must only remove posts specifically identified to it. A Frankfurt regional court granted her claim in 2022; the higher regional court upheld the injunction but dismissed the damages in 2024.

The questions ask whether a social network that does not review posts is fully a controller under the GDPR, whether ranking and recommending posts by algorithm excludes hosting protection under the E-Commerce Directive and the Digital Services Act, whether platforms can be required to assess equivalent content manually, and whether the hosting privilege covers GDPR damages claims. According to beck-aktuell, the senate doubted that earlier CJEU rulings, including one finding a marketplace operator a GDPR controller of data in user ads, transfer to this case. No date for a ruling has been set.

Read the full article at PPC Land

Our take

If the EU court finds that algorithmic ranking ends hosting protection, marketplaces and ad platforms in the EU could face liability for content their feeds promote, not only content reported to them.

  • Ask EU platform and marketplace partners how they would handle a duty to find equivalent content.
  • Brands fighting impersonation should track whether the search burden shifts to platforms.
  • No ruling date is set, so this is a multi-year watch item.

Was our take useful?

Key takeaways

  1. Germany's top civil court referred six platform liability questions to the CJEU
  2. Plaintiff, identified as Renate Künast by German media, seeks at least 10,000 euros
  3. Key question: does algorithmic curation strip hosting protection under the DSA