Updated ETGet the DI Daily by Email

Technology news for e-commerce professionals, with our take on why it matters.

EU court adviser says services paid for with personal data cannot be called free

EU court adviser says services paid for with personal data cannot be called free
Image: PPC Land

The opinion in a German case over Facebook's 2015 sign-up slogan is not binding, and the EU court has set no judgment date.

Source: PPC Land

Advocate General Laila Medina told the Court of Justice of the European Union on November 19, 2026, that a service requiring consumers to disclose personal data and consent to its commercial use cannot be described as "free" under EU consumer law, PPC Land reported. The case, C-643/25, was brought by German consumer federation vzbv against Meta Platforms Ireland over the line "Facebook ist und bleibt kostenlos" (Facebook is and remains free) on Facebook's German registration page in February 2015.

The opinion reads "cost" in point 20 of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive's blacklist as covering personal data and consent, unless the data are processed only to supply the service or meet legal obligations. Blacklisted practices are unfair without testing whether consumers were actually misled. Medina also wrote that a complete GDPR privacy notice does not make a "free" label acceptable. The court's press release said businesses "remain free to offer services in exchange for personal data, but cannot describe them as 'free' where such consideration is required."

Point 20 applies to every trader selling to EU consumers, so the reading would reach any app, platform or site whose sign-up data funds advertising if the Court agrees, according to PPC Land. The opinion is not binding, the judges have begun deliberating and no judgment date has been given. The opinion does not decide whether passively collected data such as cookies count as payment.

Read the full article at PPC Land

Our take

Free accounts, apps and loyalty programs funded by customer data and advertising are common in commerce, and this reading would ban the "free" label on them across the EU without any consumer-confusion test.

  • Ask legal which EU offers marked free collect data beyond what running the service needs.
  • Watch for the Court's ruling, which has no date yet.
  • Track the Commission's proposed Digital Fairness Act, which would replace this directive.

Was our take useful?

Key takeaways

  1. EU adviser says data-for-service offers cannot be marketed as free (non-binding)
  2. Point 20 of the consumer blacklist applies to every trader selling to EU consumers
  3. No judgment date set; data used only to run the service stays exempt